Phil Roe's Truthiness Woes Pt. 7

10/06/10

Phil Roe's Truthiness Woes Pt. 7

Permalink 04:08:56 pm, Categories: Tennessee Politics  


This man is becoming an absolute expert in lying, bold-faced, to his constituency. Sad thing is, those who vote for him are either too stupid to fact check him, or too lacking in self-respect to care.

From the desk of TN-1 Republican Rep. Phil Roe…

EPA Policies Are Hurting Jobs, Economy

Since the Senate will not pass the flawed cap and trade legislation, the Administration is taking matters into their own hands, using the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as their lead enforcement agency. New regulations planned by the EPA could have detrimental effects to our economy – particularly causing a loss of jobs, impeding economic recovery and harming livelihoods.

Last week, I joined other members of the Rural America Solutions Group for a forum to discuss harmful regulations that may be imposed by the Obama Administration’s EPA and have already been championed by the Democratic leadership in Congress. Included in this forum were seven panelists from across the country who offered perspective and real-life examples on how these regulations could hurt job creation and economic growth. Overwhelmingly, the panelists agreed that EPA’s policies are overreaching, burdensome regulations.

Let’s see…no facts offered about how Cap&Trade is “flawed". I guess we just have to take the word of a proven liar on that.
:roll:

Rural American Solutions Group? Why you patronizing, smart-assed little Gerbil-faced geek.

Why did you neglect to mention that this “group” was concocted by your fellow lying creep, John Boehner?
As the GOP website clearly reveals…
” Rural American Solutions Group Unveiled
Posted April 30, 2009

The Rural American Solutions Group will focus on developing solutions to address issues facing rural America. House Republican Leader John Boehner (OH), Rep. Doc Hastings (WA), Rep. Frank Lucas (OK), Rep. Sam Graves (MO) and other House Republicans unveiled the group today.

According to a press release, President Obama promised to hold a summit on rural issues in his first 100 days, but that has not happened.”

Any chance you were concerned that this “group” would be seen as the dramatically partisan joke that it actually is as opposed to the citizen’s group you attempt to present it as?
:no:

By all means, please proceed Dr. Boy-Who-Cried-Wolf…

The heart of the EPA’s regulation would be a backdoor national energy tax that will ultimately kill jobs, stop economic growth and raise the cost of energy, food and transportation. They would also double the current regulatory standard on farm dust that would make tilling a field, operating a feedlot or diving farm vehicles impossible - bringing the agriculture sector to a standstill. A representative from the Virginia Farm Bureau Federation said, “Farmers and their way of life and livelihood have never felt more challenged or threatened than they do today by the continuous onslaught of regulations and requirements from the Environmental Protection Agency…. The cost they represent will impact the economy as a whole, and this committee should not be surprised when our economy contracts and jobs are lost to foreign competition.”

Lying dog. Where do I begin?…
Fearmongering has always been a GOP staple when they don’t have an substantive argument. The EPA is entertaining lots of possible measures for making our air cleaner and our water safer to drink. Nothing is carved in stone yet and Farm Dust measures are far more complex than Mr. Roe might tell his intellectually challenged constituency.

FARM DUST: There are measures that large farms and other industries can take to greatly reduce farm Dust emissions. Farm Dust is inevitable, but it’s also a major health and environmental hazard. The EPA will assess the situation and do what is best for all concerned.
I challenge Rep. Roe to offer any factual evidence that the EPA is Obama’s personal revenge machine or that they have actively implemented any of the extreme measures he implies.

Farm Dust can be kept at a minimum and I’m confident that most farmers do their best. Corporate farms, on the other hand, probably are more likely to cut safety for profit as it is with most corporate entities. Dust emissions do require a certain amount of personal responsibility on behalf of the farmer/CEO…
“Try engineering and administrative methods first to cut dust emissions. Use good ventilation in enclosed spaces such as barns and silos. Look at how you dispense materials around the farming operation and change them to reduce the dust emissions. For example, automated feed machines, mechanical waste removal systems, and wet spray methods can all cut dust emissions. Use proper storage methods and consider changing bedding materials, feeds, chemical fertilizers, etc. to low-dust options.

When you have identified and implemented dust reduction techniques, note the remaining tasks and work areas that create dust exposures. These are the job tasks that may require respiratory protection such as a nuisance dust mask or, for more protection, an air-purifying respirator.”

“Bring agriculture to a standstill"….What an idiot. Like Democrats don’t eat.
Fearmongering dork.
:roll:

“Jobs lost to foreign competition"…. The GOP has been outsourcing American’s jobs for many decades and they are the fathers of it. This sounds especially hypocritical coming from a congressman WHO JUST VOTED AGAINST ENDING TAX BREAKS FOR COMPANIES THAT SEND OUR JOBS OVERSEAS.
HR 4213 facts HERE and HERE.

Phil Roe is all about creating jobs, for the Chinese.

In addition, a new regulation on hydraulic fracturing – considered a safe, well-regulated natural gas drilling technology under the Clean Water Act – would greatly harm domestic energy production and kill thousands of energy jobs. New relegations on solid fuel-fired boilers have also been set, and could result in tens of billions in capital costs for upgrades, in turn costing thousands of jobs because of these losses.

That is a lie. The FRAC Act of 2009 was designed to force mining and drilling companies to disclose the contents of the liquids they use to invoke “Fracturing".
First read the FACTS about HYDRO-FRAC and it will be easy to see the manipulative lies of John Boner’s puppy dog, Phil Roe…
“In June 2009 two identical bills named the FRAC Act were introduced to both the United States House and the Senate. FRAC stands for Fracturing Responsibility and Awareness of Chemicals Act. The House bill was introduced by Diana Degette, Jared Polis, and Maurice Hinchey. Bob Casey and Chuck Schumer introduced the bill to the Senate. These bills are designed to amend the Safe Drinking Water Act. This would allow the Environmental Protection Agency to regulate hydraulic fracturing that occurs in states which have not taken primacy in UIC regulation. The bill also requires the energy industry to reveal what chemicals are being used in the sand-water mixture.”

And……………..

“Some environmental and human health concerns possibly associated with hydraulic fracturing may include the potential mishandling of solid toxic waste, potential risks to air quality, potential contamination of ground water, and the unintended migration of gases and hydraulic fracturing chemicals to the surface within a given radius of drilling operations. The potential costs associated with possible environmental clean-up processes, loss of land value and human and animal health concerns are undetermined. New technological advances and appropriate state regulations are working to study and safely implement the process.

A well blowout in Clearfield County, PA on June 3, 2010 sent more than 35,000 gallons of hydraulic fracturing fluids into the air and onto the surrounding landscape in a forested area. Campers were evacuated and the company EOG Resources and the well completion company C.C. Forbes have been ordered to cease all operations in the state of Pennsylvania pending investigation. The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection has called this a “serious incident”
.
Read the whole Wiki link and it will easy for anyone to see through the lies of Phil Roe.

I am all for clean air, and I believe government should ensure that companies are playing by the rules. But what we don’t need is any more ridiculous red tape in the First District and around the country that has not been authorized by Congress and will only harm job growth in our country. We need a federal government that will focus on creating jobs, and preventing tax hikes and getting our economy back on track.

Um, no you’re not, no you don’t and if “red tape” is more of a concern to you than the health of the people in your district then I submit that you, Dr. Roe, are a quack.

Not to mention a liar.

VOTE MIKE CLARK FOR US CONGRESS. Because Phil Roe doesn’t care about you.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: E. Kokkelenberg [Visitor]
I watched the hearing “The EPA’s Assault on Rural America” on September 29, 2010, and offer the following comment. While I indeed learned something from many of the speakers, and have some understanding of a number of the areas they covered, having worked in industry for 18 years before I switched to higher education, I will confine my comments to Dr. Considine’s talk.
First, I do recognize that all had time limits which constrain how much material they can cover. But having said that, I note the Dr. Considine offered his estimate of the present value of the ‘lost’ gas production in the state of New York. I have seen some of his earlier studies and I note that he does not take into account the net costs to the state and its firms, farms, and citizens from such operations. These operations envision a well pad every 60 to 80 acres, a web of pipelines, and considerable industrialization of the landscape.
The costs will include the value of the damaged and lost timber, the removal of land from agriculture and vineyards, lost tourism, and the assault on roads, and most importantly, the costs of trying to correct the damage to the aquifers. This later cost is uncertain, but if a substantial aquifer is indeed contaminated with biocides or cyclical organics or heavy metals, or brine, it is almost impossible to clean up. Based on the experience of the drillers in Pennsylvania, such contamination has a high probability.
We hear that with proper safeguards and strict enforcement all will be well. But accidents happen, firms take shortcuts in the name of profit, and enforcement requires well trained skilled staff which seems to be lacking.

Hydro fracking in horizontal wells is a highly technical process with multiple firms involved at many stages of leasing, well siting, drilling, fracturing, reworking, and production. Yet the experience of the Mexican Gulf spill and the Challenger explosion has shown that complex responsibilities, competing goals, and decision making by multiple players in a hi-tech culture is not failsafe.

Thus, we will have contaminated aquifers. Period.
I like to see Dr. Considine’s response and calculations but I suggest that the net present value is reduced considerably and may be negative. The alternative of slowly developing this gas asset which is not going away, and taking care to be responsible about contamination may add costs, but in net present value terms may be better.

Indeed, most of the presenters seemed to have no specific alternative to what was proposed by EPA except the status quo; and therefore, they gave only a partial picture. Congressmen need full and better data to help them make an informed decision and craft legislation that is good for all. I hope they get it, they didn’t this time
PermalinkPermalink 10/09/10 @ 19:45
Comment from: captainkona [Member] Email · http://tn420.org
Thank you, E. Kokkelenberg.

That is the kind of in-depth, helpful response we like to get here.

It never ceases to amaze me how the insatiable greed of certain industrial entities can lead them to the conclusion that "oh well, if a few people or a few square miles are contaminated with whatever it will be worth what we get".

As it is with Mountain Top Removal, they don't understand, or care about, the fact that even one casualty is one too many.

The earth and it's inhabitants are expendable to the corporate elite.

I will research Dr. Considine, of whom I have never heard, and I greatly appreciate your reply. Feel free to comment here anytime. Your input is educational and well presented.

Best regards,
captainkona
PermalinkPermalink 10/09/10 @ 20:17

Leave a comment:

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
:)> => :!: :?: :idea: :) :p B) ;) :> :roll: :oops: :| :-/ :( >:( :'( |-| :>> ;D :P :)) 88| :. :no: XX( :lalala: :crazy: >:XX :DD :o 8| >:-[ :) )-o U-( :( :**: :??: :`( >:-( :## :zz: :wave:

Allowed XHTML tags: <p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small>
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email and url)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will NOT be displayed.))